skulptur projekte muenster…..an international exhibition of outdoor public art offered every ten years in Muenster, Germany. This year’s curators proclaim its purpose is to “explore the relationship between contemporary art, urban space, and the public sphere.”
documenta 12.…presented every 5 years in Kassel, Germany, this is the 12th international exhibition of artistic expression and experimental art.
AN EDUCATION IN ART
Explorations in Germany
documenta 12 and skulptur projekte ‘07
Germany as the Palette
Even today, history hangs heavy in Germany. I felt it perched solidly on my shoulder, not like the ominous raven, but more like the wise, reflective owl, often quiet, but always present…….the weight of it unrelenting. Germany is a country that has examined and reexamined itself, and it’s people have taken the lessons of history, and take themselves, very seriously. It is in this context that Muenster and Kassel chose to open themselves up for yet more introspection, more public examination, more serious thought……….. through the medium of Art.
An Education in Art
I’m not an artist, nor am I an art critic. It was my artsy son that convinced me to travel to Germany for this foray into the esoteric. But then, exhibitions of this scale are attended mostly by people like me, the curious tourist……as well as families for an enjoyable outing, and students for study and critique. As a German man who had attended many previous exhibitions told me, “One must observe with a sense of humor and not take the art too seriously.” Good advice for the accidental tourist, but having read many reviews from the critics, the art world takes these two exhibitions very, very seriously. So I set out to bridge the gap, so to speak, between art critic and art tourist…………of stretching outside my comfort zone to embrace the weird, appreciate the folly, and delve inside the soul of contemporary art.
Cityscape as Canvas
The idea of either Skulptur Projekte or Documenta taking place anywhere else but their respective cities is unimaginable. Take Muenster, a small Westphalian town of about 260,000……… People of the region will tell you with observable reverence that Muenster is different from other German cities. It is a university and banking town, prosperous, cultured, refined. As my first cab driver proudly told me in excellent English, “……..this is a city of white collar workers”.
The historical center of the city was mostly destroyed during World War II, yet, the community chose to restore Muenster with its pre-war gothic architecture retaining the charm of antiquity and integrating it with contemporary infrastructure. After the post war construction and transportation needs were addressed, the mid 70’s reflected a period of new beginnings and the undertaking of development projects. A quarrel about the use of “urban space” and “public art” ignited a critical discussion resulting in the conception of a large international exhibition named Skulptur Projekte. Initially an unpopular notion, it has now become the defining image of the city and a blueprint for all subsequent art exhibitions set in public spaces all over the world.
Muenster now views its Skulptur Projekte as a long term study which every ten years assesses the political and economic climate. Indeed, 39 works from previous years have now become treasured icons of the local landscape. In this fourth incarnation, 36 artists create site-specfic works responding to the urban context. Environmental issues take center stage in the form of Pawel Althamer’s “Path”, literally a dirt path representing “a way out of our ordered lives”. Jeremy Deller studies the very German history of allotment gardens while Tue Greenfort’s “Diffuse Entries” addresses the problem of phosphates in Muenster’s Lake Aa by placing a liquid manure truck shooting an inoculation of iron chloride into the lake to combat the algae blooms caused by the pollutants. Yes, you are right to conjure up an image of a huge silver truck spewing water into beautiful lake Aa as one of the installations. Is it ART? What exactly is ART? If the purpose of ART and Skulptur Projekte is to be provocative, then, mission accomplished. But there are other questions awaiting………
A free and clean public toilet was one of my particular favorites. Hans-Peter Feldmann’s “WC Facilities on the Domplatz” addressed the issue of the rather unpleasant, but requisite, subject of public toilets. The premise: public toilets should be free, well looked after, and attractive. Never one to pass up a free toilet, I walked down the stairs marked “Frauen” finding a pristine facility complete with a large piece of artwork and bejeweled chandelier. Much to my horror, however, the male attendant rushed in to clean each toilet stall even before the flushing stopped. Well, enough said about that.
Continuing on a theme of usefulness and practicality, a very popular installation amongst young families was Mike Kelley’s “Petting Zoo”. While the children delight in petting goat, sheep, a pony, and a loudly braying donkey, their parents can ponder the underlying theme of Sodom and Gomorrah. A life-size salt lick of Lot’s wife stands in the center of the circular barn while the animals are shown films of three different rock formations which are named for Lot’s wife. As far as I know, the animals remained mute about Lot’s wife and her fate, unless, perhaps the donkey was braying his lament. They just licked away, changing her form, which was, of course, expressing the impermanence of life and art, or do I detect a sexual allusion here?
History is inescapable, and Muenster does not avoid the confrontation. Gustav Metzger’s “Shattered Stones” gives us “randomness”. For each 107 days of the exhibition, a man drives a forklift of stones to a particular location in the city. A similar exercise was to be simultaneously articulated in the English town of Coventry, though it is still pending authorization. In 1940, the Luftwaffe razed Coventry and in retaliation, the RAF intensified its bombing of German cities. Metzer’s randomly dispersed stones represent the destruction in both cities. The stones accumulate and then disappear, a representation of devastation and reconciliation.
In another reference to the painful past, Martha Rosler’s three part series, “Unsettling Fragments”, brazenly places the German Armed Forces Eagle affixed to a pole in front of a shopping arcade. In front of the modern Public Library, she places replicas of the 3 cages from which the corpses of John of Leiden and two other Anabaptists were displayed as they hung from St. Lambert’s Church during the Reformation in 1536. As a softening effect, she then constructs a Bamboo Garden leading from St. Lambert’s Church to the Library. “From military to commerce to church to culture and to knowledge. This is how Rosler reads the city of Muenster”, states the catalogue.
The sometimes enigmatic installations of Skulptur Projekte 2007 suggest that the term “art in public space” is much too pedestrian a description for what has actually become an artistic laboratory for the discussion of the relationship between art and its public. Thoughtful indeed. But on a sunny autumn afternoon, strolling the tree-lined Promenade, watching ducks swim in the ponds, and bicyclists roll through the park, such big questions seem to dissolve into one overwhelming sentiment: the most consequential ART is life itself.
Kassel: The Ugliest City in Germany
I didn’t say that. And I don’t think that either. However, nearly every German I spoke to has mentioned it, unsolicited. In its most recent history, Kassel was a manufacturing town. During the war, except for a few historical buildings, the city center was completely destroyed and rebuilt with a 1950’s and 60’s architectural motif. We spent the first evening in a local pub where the jolly owner and patrons seemed to have dinner together every night. After my first German bratwurst, sauerkraut, and beer in the hearty atmosphere of this provincial pub, I knew I was going to like this town, architecture be damned! In fact, Kassel has embraced this quintiennial art event with aplomb and hospitable grace redeeming itself from the faux pas of past design choices.
The Journey Within
If Skulptur Projekte causes one to look outward to the relationship of the individual in the environment, Documenta elicits an inward journey, and a demanding one at that. One is often to forced to think about the unthinkable, confront the issues that haunt our fragile humanity. The obligatory political themes of colonialism, loss of native culture, tyrannical governments, and war failed to lure my attention away from the aesthetically moving, innovative pieces which tell the story of the artist’s own journey through the creative process. Piece by piece, the artwork begged the question, “What is the relationship of the artist to the artwork?” The curators had their own questions that they hoped documenta 12 would address. However, you would probably stop reading if I started to list them. To summarize, “Is art the medium for addressing the issues of the day?”
The exhibition is held in seven different locations throughout the city and takes a full two days to absorb, if you can last that long……..150 artists and 500 works later. I had already read several reviews of the exhibition which soundly panned the curators’ vision and execution. However, we are not art critics here, and we have no purpose but to enjoy the mystique and festive atmosphere of one of the most significant international art shows. Created in 1955 by the artist and art educator, Arnold Bode, the exhibition was initiated in response to the violence of Nazism with the intention of reuniting the German public with international modernity. Every 5 years, the exhibition reinvents itself with a different curator with a different vision.
documenta 12 ‘s curators endowed this exhibition with a theme of “formlessness”, and in this, they achieved their goal. Imagine………… in the newly constructed Aux Pavilion, excoriated for its vastness and “storage shed” appearance, one drifts from British-born Jo Spence’s photographic essay documenting her struggle with breast cancer to Lu Hao’s spectacular traditional Chinese scrolls recording the changes on Chang ‘An Street in Beijing to Romuald Hazoume’s amusing collection of African masks constructed of plastic containers to a film presenting the oral histories of a Kurdish society by the voices of five men. Whew! Formlessness. According to one critic, if you missed the relationship between the placement of the artworks, then you just weren’t looking hard enough. Ruth Noack, wife and partner of curator, Roger Buergel, also takes the public to task when she addressed the issue of including a number of older works dating back 600 years or more. “The point is to help educate a lay public which knows woefully little about art.”
These are a few of my fav-or-ite things……
Benin based Hazoume’s “found object” masks were particularly charming. Having lived in South Africa where “found object” art abounds, I have long admired the ability to create beauty and whimsy from materials that most people consider disposable. But no random whimsically exists here. Hazoume draws on the 4,000 year old African culture and the ceremonial bronze heads for his inspiration while mourning the loss of ancient knowledge in favor of western ideals. I liked the masks because they made me smile. Somehow, I don’t think the curators would have approved.
Throughout the exhibition, the public is invited to sit on one of the 1001 antique wooden Ch’ing Dynasty chairs collected and restored by Ai Weiwei, artist and antique aficionado. At his invitation, 1001 ordinary Chinese citizens will visit Kassel in 5 stages to experience documenta 12. Attendees were chosen from thousands of applicants, coming from different regions and never having visited a foreign country. This undertaking, an experiment exploring knowledge transmission, has the title of “Fairytale”, a regional reference to the Grimm Brothers who wrote their stories in Kassel between 1812-1815.
Film figures prominently in documenta 12 as it does in any contemporary exhibition of import. I was particularly moved by Hito Steyerl film called “Lovely Andrea”. Filmed in black and white with the author off camera, she documents a search for her own photo from some 20 years ago when she was a “bondage model” in Tokyo.
Zheng Guogu stands the ancient art of calligraphy on its head with his monolithic “Waterfall”. Hundreds of amateur calligraphers produced thousands of texts which were subsequently dipped in wax and fashioned as a waterfall. This ceremonious experiment releases calligraphy from its historical past giving it form in contemporary life.
Epilogue
I am not embarrassed to say that in many cases, I just didn’t “get it”. This is when I refer back to my German friend who told me to not to take the art too seriously. Though we, the public, “know woefully little about art”, ultimately, we are present, we are engaged, we are curious. And we desperately want ART to speak to us. As my son noted, if art is not connecting with the audience and delivering its message, then perhaps the artists have become too insular, too caught up in their own world.
So the question becomes, “Is art the medium for addressing the issues of today?” According to current definitions of modernism, it would seem that the fragmentation and subjectivity arouse a bit of discomfort in our all too uncertain world of 2007. Did documenta 12 work as a relevant exhibition, as a means of communicating the preponderance of today’s world? Happily, I am not an art critic who has to make this judgment. On this day in Kassel, it was a pleasure to be the woefully uninformed public enjoying a brat and beer at the local pub.
First published in “Expat Travel and Lifestyle”, Manila, Philippines, Vol 2 No 1 2008